Peer & AI Review + Reflection (PAIRR)

Peer & AI Review + Reflection (PAIRR) is a five-part curricular intervention: 1) Students discuss and reflect on short readings on AI. 2) They complete peer review of draft writing assignments. 3) They prompt an AI tool to review the same drafts, with instructor guidance on privacy settings. 4) They critically reflect on and assess both types of feedback, considering their goals and audience(s), and 5) They revise.

Developed and tested in 10 courses with 654 students at UC Davis in 2023-24, PAIRR is now expanding in 2025-2027, thanks to a 3-year, $1.5 million AI Grand Challenge grant from the California Learning Lab. We are collaborating with four Community Colleges (American River, Glendale, LA Mission, and College of Marin), three CSUs (Bakersfield, Maritime, Sacramento State) and UC Davis. PAIRR aims to increase equity in writing support and AI literacy for students and faculty, providing access to and training on appropriate AI tools, based on best practices in writing instruction. See Embracing AI in the Classroom, a UC Davis College of Letters and Science Magazine story about PAIRR's California Learning Lab grant.

A step-by-step visual representation of the PEER AND AI REVIEW + REFLECTION (PAIRR) process. The graphic consists of five staggered steps, each in a hexagonal shape with a number and description: 	1.	Draft – Students create a rough draft. 	2.	Peer Feedback – Students provide and receive peer feedback. 	3.	AI Feedback – Students enter their prompt, draft, and the assignment rubric into an AI tool. 	4.	Reflect – Students complete a comparative reflection on AI and peer feedback. 	5.	Revise – Students revise d
PAIRR graphic designed by Nicholas Stillman